January 28, 2003

 

Subjects:

 

[28/Jan/2003:21:10:39] <Father Phillip> Greetings, earthlings -- if anybody would like to ask a question, please type it into the white bar and press "enter"

 

Back to the Top

 

Baptism in Various Christian Churches

Click here to read more information on this topic.


[28/Jan/2003:21:25:38] <Father Phillip> kristin: how is catholic baptism different from that of other faiths?
[28/Jan/2003:21:25:43] <Father Phillip> hi, kristin...
[28/Jan/2003:21:25:59] <Father Phillip> well, the fact of the matter is that there is no such thing as "catholic baptism" :-)
[28/Jan/2003:21:26:08] <Father Phillip> ALL baptism(s) are Christian
[28/Jan/2003:21:26:29] <Father Phillip> in order for there to be a valid baptism the following things have to be present
[28/Jan/2003:21:26:38] <Father Phillip> water must be used
[28/Jan/2003:21:26:53] <Father Phillip> the "Trinitarian formula" must be used
[28/Jan/2003:21:27:06] <Father Phillip> that is, "I baptize you in the Name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit"
[28/Jan/2003:21:27:23] <Father Phillip> and the person ministering the baptism must intend Christian baptism to occur
[28/Jan/2003:21:27:52] <Father Phillip> the Scripture says that there is but one Lord, one faith, one baptism, and one God and Father of us all
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:03] <Father Phillip> on the basis of that sentiment expressed by Saint Paul
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:17] <Father Phillip> the Catholic Church has always contended that there is only ONE BAPTISM
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:23] <Father Phillip> and that baptism is Christian
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:38] <Father Phillip> not specifically Catholic or Methodist or Presbyterian
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:40] <Father Phillip> just Christian
[28/Jan/2003:21:28:42] <Father Phillip> ok?
[28/Jan/2003:21:29:17] <Father Phillip> kristin: yup, thanks
[28/Jan/2003:21:29:20] <Father Phillip> my pleasure
[28/Jan/2003:21:35:03] <Father Phillip> any other questions are welcome...

 

Back to the Top

 

Blessed Virgin Mary and the Saints

[28/Jan/2003:22:19:25] <Father Phillip> kristin: me again--I am asked a lot why the "obsession" with the virgin Mary and all the saints?
[28/Jan/2003:22:19:34] <Father Phillip> interesting choice of words
[28/Jan/2003:22:20:10] <Father Phillip> i would suggest that we neither are nor should we be "obsessed" with the Virgin Mary and/ or the saint
[28/Jan/2003:22:20:12] <Father Phillip> s
[28/Jan/2003:22:20:50] <Father Phillip> rather I think it would be appropriate to say that both the Mother of Jesus and the saints provide us with valuable insights and guides into how living a Christian life can best be done
[28/Jan/2003:22:21:15] <Father Phillip> i think that we would be foolish not to take every good example we can possibly get
[28/Jan/2003:22:21:31] <Father Phillip> for heaven's sake the counter spirit is constantly giving people a BAD example
[28/Jan/2003:22:21:43] <Father Phillip> so why shouldn't we use all the GOOD examples that we possibly can
[28/Jan/2003:22:22:06] <Father Phillip> and certainly Mary and the saints give us some EXCELLENT examples and insights about how best to live as followers of Christ
[28/Jan/2003:22:22:13] <Father Phillip> make sense?

Back to the Top

 

The Catholic View of Jesus as Savior in Relation to the Saints

Click here for more information on this topic.


[28/Jan/2003:22:25:27] <Father Phillip> kristin: yes--I guess it's just that others, particularly more evangelical denominations (or whatever the word may be) are just about solely focused on Jesus as savior. Just a difference i guess
[28/Jan/2003:22:25:46] <Father Phillip> you're right -- it is a difference
[28/Jan/2003:22:25:57] <Father Phillip> i would say that we are focused on Jesus as saviour!
[28/Jan/2003:22:26:11] <Father Phillip> but there's more to living a Christian life than just being "saved"
[28/Jan/2003:22:26:18] <Father Phillip> salvation is important, to be sure
[28/Jan/2003:22:26:22] <Father Phillip> but it's only the beginning
[28/Jan/2003:22:26:50] <Father Phillip> "after" we're "saved" we have to figure out how to live each day as followers of the Jesus Who has saved us
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:01] <Father Phillip> in many ways, that's the really hard part of being Christian
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:08] <Father Phillip> accepting Jesus is fairly simple
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:24] <Father Phillip> He is, after all, a very attractive, wonderful, kind, compassionate, interesting Person
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:32] <Father Phillip> so accepting Him isn't all that difficult
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:41] <Father Phillip> the hard part, really, comes after we've accepted Him
[28/Jan/2003:22:27:57] <Father Phillip> and Mary and the saints give us some good clues about how to walk with Him each day
[28/Jan/2003:22:28:15] <Father Phillip> in technical theological language, that's called "sanctifying grace"
[28/Jan/2003:22:34:23] <Father Phillip> Nick: Hey there.
[28/Jan/2003:22:34:28] <Father Phillip> Nick: How are you?
[28/Jan/2003:22:34:36] <Father Phillip> hey...i'm ok, thanks -- how 'bout you?
[28/Jan/2003:22:34:51] <Father Phillip> Nick: good good
[28/Jan/2003:22:34:54] <Father Phillip> glad to hear it
[28/Jan/2003:22:35:53] <Father Phillip> Nick: I might accidently log-off becuase I'm having internet problems but if it happens Ill come back
[28/Jan/2003:22:35:56] <Father Phillip> that's cool
[28/Jan/2003:22:36:02] <Father Phillip> i'm here for a bit :-)
[28/Jan/2003:22:36:10] <Father Phillip> what can i do to help you?

Back to the Top

 

Drinking Alcohol


[28/Jan/2003:22:36:35] <Father Phillip> Nick: Ok, so what does our religion say about drinking alcohol?
[28/Jan/2003:22:36:39] <Father Phillip> Nick: Is it a sin?
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:00] <Father Phillip> as with many things, Catholicism is ok with drinking alchohol as long as it's done responsibly
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:10] <Father Phillip> that is, never in combination with driving
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:20] <Father Phillip> never as an excuse to do something immoral
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:31] <Father Phillip> never as an excuse to take advantage of another person
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:42] <Father Phillip> but is drinking alcohol a sin: nope
[28/Jan/2003:22:37:47] <Father Phillip> Nick: wow thats cool
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:06] <Father Phillip> yeah, actually, Catholicism is generally pretty cool
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:11] <Father Phillip> Nick: i was expected a nonono badbadbad kind of answer
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:18] <Father Phillip> it can be badbadbad
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:22] <Father Phillip> if it's abused
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:25] <Father Phillip> like anything
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:33] <Father Phillip> if it's MIS-used, it can be bad
[28/Jan/2003:22:38:44] <Father Phillip> but there's nothing intrinsically bad about alcohol

 

Back to the Top

 

Use of Tobacco

[28/Jan/2003:22:38:49] <Father Phillip> Nick: ok, and what about smoking?
[28/Jan/2003:22:39:00] <Father Phillip> hummm...that one is a little bit harder
[28/Jan/2003:22:39:13] <Father Phillip> our bodies are precious gifts from God
[28/Jan/2003:22:39:21] <Father Phillip> we have an obligation to care for our bodies
[28/Jan/2003:22:39:39] <Father Phillip> while drinking alcohol in moderation can even be good for the body
[28/Jan/2003:22:39:52] <Father Phillip> smoking is pretty generally thought always to be bad for the body
[28/Jan/2003:22:40:16] <Father Phillip> so, i would have to conclude that smoking is in a pretty different category than drinking alcohol IN MODERATION and carefully
[28/Jan/2003:22:43:53] <Father Phillip> Nick: Sorry about that father
[28/Jan/2003:22:43:55] <Father Phillip> about what?
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:01] <Father Phillip> you get booted?
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:07] <Father Phillip> Nick: leaving
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:10] <Father Phillip> no biggie
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:17] <Father Phillip> Nick: I looked up something and it took me off the site
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:20] <Father Phillip> 's cool
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:37] <Father Phillip> Nick: so about the smoking..
[28/Jan/2003:22:44:51] <Father Phillip> did you miss my whole answer about smoking?
[28/Jan/2003:22:45:41] <Father Phillip> Nick: i only saw the part where you said that our bodies are gifts from god
[28/Jan/2003:22:45:47] <Father Phillip> ok -- to recap :-)
[28/Jan/2003:22:45:57] <Father Phillip> since our bodies are gifts from God
[28/Jan/2003:22:46:03] <Father Phillip> we have an obligation to take care of them
[28/Jan/2003:22:46:22] <Father Phillip> while drinking can even be good for our bodies when done in MODERATION,
[28/Jan/2003:22:46:36] <Father Phillip> most scientists tell us that smoking is almost always bad for our bodies
[28/Jan/2003:22:46:53] <Father Phillip> so, smoking is in a pretty different category than drinking
[28/Jan/2003:22:46:55] <Father Phillip> make sense?
[28/Jan/2003:22:47:21] <Father Phillip> Nick: yes
[28/Jan/2003:22:47:28] <Father Phillip> ok
[28/Jan/2003:22:47:38] <Father Phillip> drinking: check; smoking: no check
[28/Jan/2003:22:47:45] <Father Phillip> :-)
[28/Jan/2003:22:48:17] <Father Phillip> Nick: lol
[28/Jan/2003:22:48:32] <Father Phillip> how IM-ish of you

Back to the Top

 

After Death

[28/Jan/2003:22:49:28] <Father Phillip> Nick: next, if you damage your brain or get "less intelligent" while being here on earth, can that affect your after life?
[28/Jan/2003:22:49:32] <Father Phillip> i don't think so
[28/Jan/2003:22:49:49] <Father Phillip> life after death depends on God's goodness -- not on our brains
[28/Jan/2003:22:50:07] <Father Phillip> the after life is God's great gift of being in God's Presence for all eternity
[28/Jan/2003:22:50:27] <Father Phillip> not even Einstein was "smart enough" to deserve or to comprehend that
[28/Jan/2003:22:51:14] <Father Phillip> Nick: according to our beliefs, do we keep the knowledge we gathered here on earth?
[28/Jan/2003:22:51:21] <Father Phillip> that's a bit complex
[28/Jan/2003:22:51:48] <Father Phillip> as Catholics we believe that in life after death we will be distinct, clearly individuated human beings
[28/Jan/2003:22:51:58] <Father Phillip> the SAME human beings that we are in this life
[28/Jan/2003:22:52:21] <Father Phillip> however, in heaven, since we will be in God's Presence, our knowledge will be perfected
[28/Jan/2003:22:52:49] <Father Phillip> so, in a way, i suppose it would be correct to say that we "keep the knowledge we gathered on earth" BUT
[28/Jan/2003:22:52:55] <Father Phillip> that knowledge will be complete
[28/Jan/2003:22:53:09] <Father Phillip> whereas here on earth, in this life, all knowledge is incomplete

Back to the Top

 

The Use of Medicines

[28/Jan/2003:22:59:27] <Father Phillip> Nick: ok , great! The other thing is I've bene hearing things about people who believe that certain medications etc. can destroy the soul. How do we feel about this? Can anything we do inthe physical world damage our souls?
[28/Jan/2003:22:59:56] <Father Phillip> of course, stuff we do in the physical world can damage our souls
[28/Jan/2003:23:00:27] <Father Phillip> if we become physically addicted to a drug, that can diminish the capacity of our souls to hear and respond to God's Spirit
[28/Jan/2003:23:00:57] <Father Phillip> if we refuse to go to Church because "we're too tired" that, also, can minimize our soul's ability to be in Communion with God
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:04] <Father Phillip> having said that
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:19] <Father Phillip> i certainly do NOT believe that any medication can destroy a soul
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:28] <Father Phillip> the soul is immortal
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:34] <Father Phillip> it can't be destroyed
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:38] <Father Phillip> impaired, yes, possibly
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:41] <Father Phillip> but destroyed?
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:50] <Father Phillip> nope -- can't be done by a medication
[28/Jan/2003:23:01:54] <Father Phillip> or anything

Back to the Top

 

Healing of the Soul

[28/Jan/2003:23:03:12] <Father Phillip> Nick: I'm currently quitting smoking and I decided to stop using marijuana once and for all. I was never addicted to marijuana, but once you overcome an addiction or something of the sort is it posible to "heal" your soul?
[28/Jan/2003:23:03:30] <Father Phillip> no -- YOU can't "heal" your soul
[28/Jan/2003:23:03:34] <Father Phillip> but God can!
[28/Jan/2003:23:03:40] <Father Phillip> and God wants to heal your soul
[28/Jan/2003:23:03:48] <Father Phillip> and God wants to heal every human being's soul
[28/Jan/2003:23:04:04] <Father Phillip> you can co-operate with God
[28/Jan/2003:23:04:16] <Father Phillip> but none of us can do it on our own
[28/Jan/2003:23:04:18] <Father Phillip> we need God
[28/Jan/2003:23:04:27] <Father Phillip> and we need a community of persons who are open to God
[28/Jan/2003:23:04:48] <Father Phillip> that triangle works pretty well: God-you-community

Back to the Top

 

Use of Medications, cont.

[28/Jan/2003:23:05:27] <Father Phillip> Nick: Is there anything wrong with taking certain medications, example: Acne medications, cancer treatments
[28/Jan/2003:23:05:46] <Father Phillip> from a Catholic perspective, i can think of nothing at all wrong with taking certain medications
[28/Jan/2003:23:06:01] <Father Phillip> there are some, rare circumstances in which taking a particular medication might be wrong
[28/Jan/2003:23:06:27] <Father Phillip> but as a rule, Catholicism sees medication as yet another example of God's desire to bring wholeness to us
[28/Jan/2003:23:06:39] <Father Phillip> used responsibly and carefully, meds are fine
[28/Jan/2003:23:07:15] <Father Phillip> Nick: So acne medications are o.k?
[28/Jan/2003:23:07:19] <Father Phillip> yes...mostly
[28/Jan/2003:23:07:34] <Father Phillip> there are some acne meds that are also artificial birth control pills
[28/Jan/2003:23:07:56] <Father Phillip> those might be problematic for women
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:00] <Father Phillip> Nick: I shouldn;t be thinking God made me a guy that has acne and I should accept it not try and fight it off?
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:05] <Father Phillip> of course not!
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:11] <Father Phillip> do you fly in airplanes?
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:19] <Father Phillip> God didn't give you wings
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:25] <Father Phillip> but it's ok to fly in a plane
[28/Jan/2003:23:08:56] <Father Phillip> if acne is a problem for you, and if God has given you the medical means to fight it, go for it!
[28/Jan/2003:23:09:00] <Father Phillip> Nick: good point
[28/Jan/2003:23:09:06] <Father Phillip> yeah, i'm full of good points :-)

Back to the Top

 

The Second Coming of Jesus and the Presence of Christ in the Community

[28/Jan/2003:23:09:44] <Father Phillip> Nick: why do you think God doesn;t send another 'Jesus' down to earth?
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:12] <Father Phillip> as Catholics we believe that Jesus will come again at the end of time -- we say it every Sunday when we pray the Creed together at Mass
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:18] <Father Phillip> Nick: why won;t God just show up?
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:26] <Father Phillip> but, God does "just show up"
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:38] <Father Phillip> God asks YOU and me to be His Presence in the world every single day
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:43] <Father Phillip> when people look at you
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:46] <Father Phillip> when people look at me
[28/Jan/2003:23:10:58] <Father Phillip> God asks us to be God's very Presence to those people
[28/Jan/2003:23:11:24] <Father Phillip> i think the reason that God doesn't send "another Jesus down to earth" is that God already made those arrangements, so to speak
[28/Jan/2003:23:11:38] <Father Phillip> God has asked that all Christians be the Presence of Christ in our world
[28/Jan/2003:23:11:53] <Father Phillip> so, if you and i are doing our "job", Christ is already here!
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:00] <Father Phillip> pretty awesome, no?
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:05] <Father Phillip> Nick: But what I mean is why doesn't he just come as a ray of light and say some words..
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:14] <Father Phillip> Nick: to help build faith/restore faith
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:17] <Father Phillip> good question
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:33] <Father Phillip> but in all honesty, i think God DOES come as a ray of light
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:41] <Father Phillip> i think God DOES say some words
[28/Jan/2003:23:12:54] <Father Phillip> at every Liturgy, i truly hear God's voice and see God's light
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:26] <Father Phillip> so very many times when i see undergrads getting up and going to cook at the IFC Food Shelter at 5:30 a.m. on Tuesdays
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:32] <Father Phillip> THAT is God speaking
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:42] <Father Phillip> those undergrads ARE God's Presence!
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:46] <Father Phillip> Nick: I know but I mean like a physical appearence
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:51] <Father Phillip> Nick: You hear a physical voice?
[28/Jan/2003:23:13:56] <Father Phillip> well, yes, sort of
[28/Jan/2003:23:14:15] <Father Phillip> the Church says that when the Word is proclaimed in Liturgy, it REALLY is Christ speaking
[28/Jan/2003:23:14:34] <Father Phillip> and surely when i receive the Eucharist, i know i am receiving His REAL PRESENCE
[28/Jan/2003:23:14:45] <Father Phillip> but i understand your point
[28/Jan/2003:23:14:56] <Father Phillip> my point, though, is that God wants us to be Christ
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:05] <Father Phillip> God wants us to speak Christ's Word to each other
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:22] <Father Phillip> God doesn't want to put on a magic show that would wow us into believing
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:38] <Father Phillip> rather i think God wants us to take deep and personal responsibility
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:42] <Father Phillip> to be Christ to one another
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:47] <Father Phillip> to see Christ in each other
[28/Jan/2003:23:15:51] <Father Phillip> that's a lot harder
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:03] <Father Phillip> but, in the long run, i think it's far more meaningful
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:08] <Father Phillip> Nick: Anyway I know the time is up and I'll let you go! ;) Thank you sooooo much I've learnt so much..!
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:11] <Father Phillip> very cool
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:16] <Father Phillip> i've enjoyed chatting with you
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:24] <Father Phillip> i'll actually be moderating again next tuesday
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:31] <Father Phillip> so, maybe i'll get to see you again
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:35] <Father Phillip> take care!
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:39] <Father Phillip> blessings one and all!
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:53] <Father Phillip> Nick: yes thank you! ill be back!
[28/Jan/2003:23:16:57] <Father Phillip> cool, i'll count on it!
[28/Jan/2003:23:17:03] <Father Phillip> good night!
[28/Jan/2003:23:17:11] <Father Phillip> Nick: good night

Back to the Top